Return of the slasher nurse.
JBB Featured Film Reviewer

Ben Nagy reviews ‘Return of the Slasher Nurse’: Her Last Name Ain’t Nightingale, and Her Sister’s No Better

A killer in a nurse's outfit and her sister kill a bunch of people while a couple of their victims' relative decide to go after em in "Return of the Slasher Nurse," an indy horror flick out of Orange County, Virginia.

Orange County, Virginia’s answer to Leatherface uses an axe and goes out killing a whole mess of folks with her younger sister

This week’s feature is Return of the Slasher Nurse. I was unaware that there was a Slasher Nurse to begin with, so this is another one of those cases where I’m getting my feet wet on a series well after the first flick was unleashed.

The first flick put out with the Anneke Mitchell Slasher Nurse character was Curse of the Slasher Nurse by David Kerr’s Slasher 15 production company out in Virginia. This sequel doesn’t waste time getting rolling.

We start out with Lily (Lilian Kerr), the younger sister of the original Slasher Nurse, walking home with her frenemy Alice through the woods after a day at school. Both of them are early teens, and after Alice tells Lily not to hang out with her at school because she’s so weird, Lily gets Alice to go off screen into the woods and get killed.

Alice’s Grandpa Roger notices that Alice hasn’t come home yet, finds some blood out in the woods and goes straight to Lily’s Aunt Lisa’s house to confront them. For his trouble and for threatening to call the cops, he gets scalped with a pair of hedging shears. So two dead bodies in the first five minutes or so, a promising initial body count …

and cue the opening credits with a newspaper clip montage on what happened in the first flick — basically there’s a woman in a nurse’s outfit roaming around Orange County, Virginia, making campers disappear and her sister might have a connection to it. Ya think? Cause if not, angry Grandpa Roger was scalped in vain.

After the opening credits, there’s a 10-member UFO flying-saucer Chariots of the Gods cult led by a dude named Theo meeting out in the woods. Seven of the 10 die after consuming a Jim Jones special, the Slasher Nurse (Kea Morbidrella Raines, who helped do the special effects) axes Theo in the head. A woman cult member gets a ball bat to the head from the more grown-up Lily (Amber Fulcher, who also helped to do the special effects), then a pitchfork through the leg and then gets axed by the Slasher Nurse and finally, William, a clumsy guy who was just in the cult for the chicks and fouled up the ceremony becomes the last victim — so 12 dead bodies in the first 15 minutes.

Ben Nagy reviews 'Return of the Slasher Nurse': Her Last Name Ain't Nightingale, and Her Sister's No Better 1
Here’s Anneke Mitchell, aka the Slasher Nurse. Her bedside manner is a bit choppy. (Screen capture from DVD by reviewer Ben Nagy).

This pace isn’t maintained because now we’ve got to get to the plot part of the flick. We meet our protagonist, Kara Warden (Alaina Alfaro), whose sister is missing, presumably a prior victim of the Slasher Nurse. She visits her therapist and confronts a now-retired police officer who was in charge of the case because she feels he didn’t put enough pressure on the Mitchell sisters’ father. She meets up with Jax (Joshua Shifflett), the brother of another victim, and they decide to take matters in their own hands with Lily and Anneke’s dad and this course of action has em end up with both police and the two homicidal sisters on their tails.

The next hour and a half has a lot of deaths, but a lot of talking too, which puts the flick at almost two hours of running time total. We also have all the three B’s accounted for, especially the first one, as evidenced below.

Ben Nagy reviews 'Return of the Slasher Nurse': Her Last Name Ain't Nightingale, and Her Sister's No Better 2
  • Best Way to Get Rid of the Popular Kid in School: In the first scene, Lily takes a claw hammer to Alice in the woods after getting called weird and a charity case. One thing, though, if the girl got bludgeoned, the sound effect sounded more like a serrated metal blade rather than a skull-crushing attack with a blunt object.
Ben Nagy reviews 'Return of the Slasher Nurse': Her Last Name Ain't Nightingale, and Her Sister's No Better 3
Grandpa Roger loses his scalp but remarkably retains the majority of his cerebrum in the second kill of the flick, even though the hedge clippers should have cut straight through. (Screen capture from DVD by reviewer Ben Nagy)
  • Best Way to Get Rid of the Angry Relative of the Dead Girl: Aunt Lisa’s disposal of Grandpa Roger exposes his brain. They were really, really good hedge clippers and somehow left the top part of the brain intact while cutting through the rest of the skull.
  • Best Alternative Use of a Kitchen Utensil: Back when she was in a care facility, Anneke stabs one of her caretakers a bunch of times with a fork, presumably killing her.
  • Best Random Homage: We get a scene where the Slasher Nurse diversifies into bludgeoning when she uses a mini sledge on Kara’s roommate Jen as she was taking a shower, a riff on the scene in Psycho, complete with blood going down the drain.
  • Best Use of One-Liners: “Big Mike” (Stephen Timothy Hudson III), he of the impressively customized license plate, reels off “I hope this girl likes astronauts because I’m out of this world,” and “I hope this girl likes her eggs scrambled and fertilized” and “Let’s rewrite the alphabet tonight and put u and I together.” He avoids getting his night cut short when he and Lily profess mutual respect for their pickup trucks.
Ben Nagy reviews 'Return of the Slasher Nurse': Her Last Name Ain't Nightingale, and Her Sister's No Better 4
A machete ends up in the tail end of Rob (Wayne Townsend), but-t (hiya, Diana) if the dialogue at the end of the flick is to be believed, he got better. (Screen capture from DVD by reviewer Ben Nagy).
  • Best Reversal of Fortune: Rob (Wayne Townsend) has a sexcapade gone wrong when he gets a machete where food goes out and a sex toy where the food is supposed to go in. Amazingly durable, he survives, but “his ass really hurts.” During the closing credits, we are reassured that “No Assholes Were Harmed in the Making of This Film,” so good on Rob for having the world’s most durable sphincter.
  • Special Mention for a Good Try: Gotta feel for Spartacus (Spartacus Jones), who not only has to suffer Tom’s foolery thinking that his Confederate flag boxers are actually Malcolm X boxers, but he then gets double-teamed by the Mitchell sisters and chopped up into kindling wood after putting up a valiant fight.

This one has limb choppings, head squishings, axe attacks, garbonza slicing, there’s a chainsaw dismemberment of a bootleg Tyler Perry DVD dealer (work on the exposure in those night scenes, though, David) and some slice-of-life Orange County, Virginia, scenes with a few witty one-liners and about 12 kilotons of F-bombs. But, as mentioned, some of the talking scenes could have been trimmed, especially as Jackson and Kara take refuge in their safe house that ends up being not-so-safe after all.

The Piedmont’s version of Leatherface and her sis get two stars in this outing. Check it out.

Return of the Slasher Nurse is available streaming on Amazon or you can acquire the DVD or BluRay directly from Slasher 15 on their website.

Share this post with friends

Let Ben know what you think: